Amazon Is Secretly Killing Your E-Commerce Brand (Here’s How to Fix It)

Jason Kutasi is the founder and CEO of SkyHouse, a performance marketing agency that managed $50M in ad spend for 2025 - its first full year of business. He’s driven roughly $500M in advertising over his career and built a children’s book publisher acquired by Scholastic and a digital marketing platform acquired by Capital One.  Jason specializes in copywriting, funnel analytics, and scaling high-growth DTC and telemedicine brands. Highlight Bullets > Here’s a glimpse of what you would learn….  E-commerce growth strategies and challenges. Comparison of selling on Amazon versus Shopify. Importance of average order value (AOV) in scaling advertising. Strategies to increase AOV, such as product bundling and premium versions. The role of TikTok and other platforms in e-commerce marketing. Managing advertising campaigns and the balance between creative volume and quality. The significance of agency versus in-house marketing teams. The impact of AI on marketing and the importance of human expertise. Insights on effective copywriting and video content in advertising. The future of e-commerce marketing and the evolving landscape of digital advertising. In this episode of the E-comm Breakthrough Podcast, host Josh Hadley speaks with Jason Kutasi, CEO of Skyhouse, about scaling e-commerce brands. They discuss the importance of average order value (AOV), emphasizing that brands need at least $60 in margin to run profitable paid ads. Jason contrasts Amazon-first versus Shopify-first strategies, recommends bundling and subscriptions to boost AOV, and advises starting with freelancers before scaling with agencies and in-house teams. They also explore Meta advertising, creative quality versus volume, and how AI augments—but doesn't replace—skilled marketers and copywriters. Here are the 3 action items that Josh identified from this episode: Fix Your AOV Before Scaling Ads Don’t run paid ads until your average order value and margins can support CAC. Aim for $60+ margin per order using bundles, upsells, or subscriptions. Build on Shopify, Use Amazon as a Bonus Channel Prioritize DTC (Shopify) to control pricing, data, and AOV—then layer Amazon as an incremental revenue stream, not your foundation. Test Creatives Broadly, Then Double Down on Winners Launch multiple ad variations quickly, identify what works, and scale only high-performing creatives with better production and audience targeting. Timestamps: 00:00:00 Introduction to the AOV Problem Jason Kutasi explains that Amazon sellers often struggle to scale on other platforms due to a low Average Order Value. 00:00:34 Host & Guest Introduction Host Josh Hadley introduces the episode's topic and guest Jason Kutasi, founder and CEO of performance marketing agency Skyhouse. 00:02:26 Amazon vs. Shopify Mindset A discussion on the two primary approaches to starting an e-commerce business and the challenges faced by Amazon-first brands. 00:03:39 The $60 Margin Rule Jason explains why brands need at least $60 in margin to profitably acquire customers on paid ad platforms like Meta. 00:04:37 Strategies to Increase AOV Actionable ways to increase Average Order Value, including creating sister brands, bundling products, and offering aggressive subscription models. 00:07:56 The "Shopify First" Advantage The benefits of a higher AOV, which provides more margin to scale advertising across multiple channels beyond Amazon PPC. 00:10:30 Why You Must Be Omnichannel Jason argues that Shopify brands should sell on Amazon to avoid losing customers who prefer to purchase there. 00:14:01 Case Study: A Massive Meta Ad Win Jason details a recent successful video ad campaign that scaled to thousands of orders in a single weekend. 00:20:04 Navigating Meta's Andromeda Update A discussion on Meta's shift to creative-driven campaigns and the strategy of slicing avatars for better, more stable performance. 00:23:34 Agency vs. In-House Teams Jason breaks down when to hire a freelancer, an agency, or build an in-house team for your marketing efforts. 00:29:13 Why Most Marketing Agencies Fail Jason shares his experience with underperforming agencies and what brand owners should look for when hiring one. 00:33:28 Building an In-House Team Alongside an Agency The importance of building an internal team to de-risk your business and test new offers before scaling with an agency. 00:36:38 The Future of E-commerce and AI Jason predicts AI will commoditize ad creation, making predictive modeling and data-driven rules the new competitive edge. 00:41:42 AI as a Human Amplifier AI won't replace skilled marketers but will augment their abilities, allowing them to perform at a much higher level. 00:44:43 Three Actionable Takeaways The host summarizes the episode's key lessons: fix your AOV, build in-house, and leverage AI with smart people. 00:49:33 Jason's Final Recommendations Jason shares his most influential book, favorite AI tool (Claude Code), and a respected figure in the e-commerce space. Resources mentioned in this episode: Josh Hadley on LinkedIn eComm Breakthrough Consulting eComm Breakthrough Podcast Email Josh Hadley: Josh@eCommBreakthrough.com Tools and Websites "Amazon": "00:02:26" "Shopify": "00:02:26" "Meta (Facebook/Instagram Ads)": "00:02:56" "Google Ads": "00:02:56" "YouTube Ads": "00:02:56" "TikTok": "00:06:23" "PayPal": "00:11:49" "Apple Pay": "00:11:49" "Google Pay": "00:11:49" "Shop Pay": "00:11:49" "Claude Code": "00:50:05" "Meta": "00:38:16" Books "The E-Myth by Michael E. Gerber": "00:00:56" "Cash Flow": "00:49:36" Videos "Video Ads": "00:14:01" Notable Mentions / People "Skyhouse (Jason Kutasi's performan...

See All Episodes