Beyond the Dieline - How Chris Kirby built Ithaca Hummus (part 1)

You know those origin stories that sound a little too clean? This isn’t one of them. In the first episode of Beyond the Dieline’s Founders Edition, Tom Seymour sits down with Chris Kirby, the chef who left the kitchen, grabbed an ice cream scooper, and started selling hummus at the Ithaca Farmers Market. No big master plan. No deep-pocketed investors. Just a stubborn belief that hummus could taste better than the stuff already on the shelf, and that if he got people to try it, the rest would figure itself out. Chris walks through the real early days: the high-school and culinary-school background, the moment he decided restaurant life wasn’t for him, and those first weekends standing at the market handing out samples until his arm got tired. Then the conversation gets into the category itself. Sabra had done the hard work of making hummus feel normal (even cool) instead of “weird lunchbox food.” But once the category blew up, value engineering took over and everything started tasting… fine. Same-ish. Chris saw an opening for something that actually tasted like it was made by someone who cared. The packaging story is especially good. People look at those distinctive square white tubs and assume it was a calculated branding move to stand out. Chris is refreshingly blunt about it: they ended up in square containers because LiDestri already had the tooling, and retooling for round cups would have cost about $60,000 they simply didn’t have. Constraint became the differentiator. Combined with High Pressure Processing (HPP) arriving in Western New York through the FLX Foods, Wegmans, and LiDestri partnership, that decision helped turn a local farmers-market product into a national brand without sacrificing the cold-crafted, fresh-ingredient approach Chris refused to compromise on. They wrap by talking about luck, not as magic, but as preparation meeting opportunity, and tease a Part 2 that digs into the later scaling challenges, packaging evolution, and everything that happened after the early wins. Key Moments00:00 – Welcome to Beyond the Dieline01:00 – How Tom and Chris first connected03:00 – Origin story: chef life to “what am I actually going to do?”08:00 – Farmers market days: sampling, feedback, and early validation13:00 – Sabra, the sea of sameness, and why the category was ready for something better17:30 – The real (and slightly accidental) story behind the square tubs19:00 – HPP, the right partners, and preparation meeting opportunity21:50 – Wrap-up and the Part 2 teaser A couple of lines that stuck“The reason we’re in square packaging is because we didn’t have any money.”“Sabra took the category from weird to cool… then value engineering started happening… and you ended up with a complete sea of sameness.”“Luck is where preparation meets opportunity.” This is Part 1. Chris and Tom plan to pick it back up soon to get into the harder, less-glamorous middle of building the business. If you like founder stories that skip the highlight reel and talk about the actual constraints, partnerships, and stubborn product decisions that shape a brand, this one’s for you. Listen above (chapters are embedded if you’re on a player that supports them) This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit encase.substack.com

See All Episodes